Hubitat vs wink

Wink is just not getting enough attention by their own company and I am fed up with their whatever it is that is going on. Was debating hard between SmartThings and Hubitat and finally came to the conclusion that Hubitat is the future. Moved into a new house and had to leave all my Caseta switches when old house was sold unfortunately. I am thinking to start over fresh again. I currently only have 4 ecobees configured into 4 different zones, myQ garage door opener, and Schlage Connect for front door and back door.

I am looking for suggestion for some custom apps for each one of these current devices that I have if there are any and also what should be something next for me to get? Thank everyone in advance!! For the ecobee thermostats, I'd recommend Universal ecobee suite from storageanarchy.

Here's the announcement from him on community. I find it to be considerably more versatile than the built-in ecobee app. It will make your z-wave devices, but especially Schlage locks, work much better with Hubitat. There are numerous threads on community.

For the MyQ, there are several integrations. Here's one that I use. Any recommendations for the z-wave extenders?

Moving From Wink to Hubitat

I don't have to use Caseta. Unfortunately it Casetas are quite expensive, any recommendations for a good smart switch and dimmers? Thank everyone! I am going thru similar process you are, trying to switch over from 2 Wink hub 2s. Finding it somewhat challenging. Say goodbye to the nice Wink color wheel for lights. This was most disappointing for me. Excellent videos for Hubitat. Including Schlage locks.

Good luck! Know I'm going to need it! I came from Wink as well. Things work much differently in Hubitat than in Wink. For example, with Wink you didn't have to pick a driver, there was no dashboard to build, you couldn't install user apps, and the "robots" are very crude compared to Hubitat's Rule Machine.

I think it is normal to feel a bit disoriented at first when making such a radical change, I know I did. There are lots of ways to handle things in Hubitat, which is one of the hard parts.

I didn't initially use Lock Code Manager, for example.Many smart home devices can't communicate with one another, which is why one of the best smart home hubs is very helpful if you want to have them all work in concert. A smart home hub not only makes sure that these devices all talk to each other, but also lets you create automations, so that when you leave your house, the hub can tell your smart lock to bolt, your smart lights to turn off, your smart thermostat to turn down, and more.

Our favorite of all the best smart home hubs is the Samsung SmartThings Hub v3. Because it has both Zigbee and Z-Wave antennas, you can pair it with a huge range of smart home devices. From within the app, you can create dozens of scenes and automations, and you can even add other family members so that they can personalize settings to their liking. It even has a home monitoring component, which can send you an alarm, record video, turn on lights, play sounds, and unlock your doors in the event of a smoke or fire alarm.

And, it now works with Nest products, something it's been missing for years. However, the 4th-generation Amazon Echo will probably appeal to more people, as it doubles as a smart speaker. It lacks Z-Wave, but has Zigbee and Bluetooth, and Amazon's Alexa app allows you to create routines that can activate your smart home devices through triggers, such as you leaving or arriving home.

Alexa Guard can also turn on smart home devices if your Echo hears a fire alarm or a window breaking. And, because the Echo is a smart speaker, you can also control your smart home devices by talking to Alexa. Size: 5. Thanks to its multiple radios, it can connect to a huge number of low-power smart home devices, and Alexa's routines are pretty sophisticated, letting you use a number of triggers to automatically activate other smart home devices. It also works with Alexa Guard, which will listen for glass breaking and smoke alarms, and can turn on your lights and notify you in the event of an emergency.

The 4th-generation Echo also supports Amazon Sidewalk, a very new low-power, long-range networking protocol, which will work with things such as Tile trackers and smart lights over much greater distances. Read our full Amazon Echo review. The third-generation Samsung SmartThings hub is our top pick of all the best smart home hubs because it has both Zigbee and Z-Wave inside, so you can connect to hundreds of devices, more than most other hubs.

What's more, the SmartThings app is loaded with functionality, which lets you create a wide range of different scenarios for all of the gadgets in your home. This version of the SmartThings hub has Wi-Fi built in, so you no longer have to plug it in to your router. That means you can place it in a location that's optimal for connecting it to all your smart home devices.Migrating over from Wink, with whom I had been with for years.

They had made a lot of improvements, but ultimately it was just too limiting on the logic it could do.

SMARTTHINGS vs. HUBITAT - Which smart home hub is best for you?

I had considered getting Smartthings, but I love Lutron products and ultimately it just didn't seem like there was enough difference to justify the switch. Apparently the jump to complicated logic and full local control pushed me over the edge for Hubitat. The process was pretty easy. I did a rolling change over - removing a few items from Wink and adding them to Hubitat.

I was surprised that the Lutron Zigbee Remote didn't work with Hubitat, but the ability to use Pico's with a Caseta Pro hub made the Zigbee remotes irrelevant anyway.

Getting my Zwave mesh up and going took a few tries - it seems that the range is less on Hubitat than it is on the Wink. That wouldn't be too surprising since the Wink has the antenna build into a larger device. Once the mesh network was up, my coverage increased and it didn't matter anyway. All it really meant was I had to move the hub around to get some of my zwave outlets that were wired in the wall. The speed difference isn't actually that much better, as Wink had been implementing local control for quite a few devices.

hubitat vs wink

What I'm loving is Room Manager. I'm coming from the commercial world of advanced lighting control, where you have one sensor that has a 5, 15, or 30 minute shut off period. Having sensors with a 30 second timeout, and having the software use the amount of activity seen over a few minutes is a totally different way of thinking for me.

It makes a lot more sense, particularly in a house. The only issue I run into is if I want the lights off while I'm in a space, as the system would keep turning them on every 30 seconds or so. I believe the solution is a button to disable the system in these situations, as they would be rare. Maybe one of those giant Fibaro red buttons that disables the whole house for the WAF. All in all I'm very pleased with Hubitat after a week of use, mainly due to the ability to use Pico switches and Room Manager.

I, too, have been considering making the jump from Wink to HEbut after reading enough posts to make my eyes bleed I can't see an advantage that goes beyond that of full local control. The USB dongle HE uses has been long discontinued by its manufacturer Nortek and the "hub" is an off the shelf device that could go the same way. When these devices are no longer in surplus, to what device will Hubitat re-direct their code and what will it cost users to remain "current"?

I'm looking for a compelling reason to move, but so far I can't find one. I migrated from Wink to HE, with a quick stopover in Smartthings. I initially made the jump from Wink out of frustration over the lack of flexibility offered by their platform. I wanted to be able to automate more of my devices but was restrained by their closed robots.Very few smart home hubs can claim they function locally.

Those that do often offer limited features when running locally. Hubitat is an exception.

The best smart home hubs of 2021

It's their second hub and an improvement over their original hub with the same name. We can break the differences down into a few points. Hubitat is a relatively new smart home hub with a rapidly growing fan base. More specifically, it can only run certain SmartApps. Hubitat has a distinct advantage when it comes to local functionality. Like other hubs, Hubitat is a central device that provides various smart home brands a platform that enables them to work together.

That said, building a Hubitat system requires adding compatible smart home products. Currently, they work with 42 brands. Note that not all products belonging to the listed brands are compatible. To avoid complications, you should research and confirm product compatibility with Hubitat before buying. You can refer to their official documented list of supported devices 1directly reach out to Hubitat Contact Usor browse their community forum Hubitat Community Forum. On a related note, Hubitat can also control some wired sensors thanks to a partnership with Konnected.

If you have a Konnected motherboard communicating with your Hubitat hub, you can even add professional monitoring through Noonlight.

Is Hubitat Elevation (Gen 2) a SmartThings Killer?

You can learn more about Konnected here. The next step is setting up the hub. Setting up the hardware is easy enough. You simply need to plug an Ethernet cable into your router and connect the power cable. Take note that although Hubitat can work offline, an internet connection is required during setup.

Once the hub has booted up, the next step is setting up the software. Go to portal. Finally, once logged in, click the Register Hub button and follow the on-screen instructions, which include naming the hub and providing your location. The third and final step is pairing devices to Hubitat. This step does not require an internet connection unless you are connecting a cloud-based product.

All you have to do is name them. Pairing cloud-based devices like Alexa, Google Assistant, Ecobee, etc. First, as mentioned above, such devices require an internet connection.

Also, you will need Apps. Apps are installable programs that give the hub added features, such as controlling cloud or IP-based products. For example, if you want to be able to control your Ecobee thermostat using Hubitat, you must install the Ecobee Integration app and log in using your Ecobee account. As another example, if you want to integrate Hubitat with Alexa, you must install the Amazon Echo App.

To install an app, simply click on the Apps button on your Hubitat dashboard and then select Load New App. Choose the right app from the list and follow the instructions on how to install and enable it. Although, at Pepcom, we were told that one is coming soon. While they make a good point, smartphone access is still somewhat vital.A smart home refers to a residence that utilizes devices connected to the internet that is used for remote monitoring, and management of home appliances.

Some common examples of these are lightning bulbs and heating appliances. Smart home technology is also commonly known as home automation. A smart home provides its resident with securitythe efficiency of energy, and comfort.

This is done by allowing them to be able to have full control over their smart devices, mostly by using voice controls or through a smart home app installed on their phones. Today, there are dozens of smart home applications available to use that are making life a lot easier. Hubitat is an internet free automation hub local-based. It is a fairly small device that connects directly to your router using an ethernet cable.

hubitat vs wink

The device does not rely on any cloud-related service, which makes it an excellent smart hub for total privacy. Ultimately, habitat is great DIY home automation. SmartThings Wi-Fi hub is a completely cloud-based smart controller that is used to control smart outlets, smart lightsand more. Basically, SmartThings is a device that makes your smart homework like it should, as well as giving you the feature of a companion app to control everything.

It is also worth mentioning that SmartThings is completely owned by Samsung. Often times, it can be hard to choose between two things. While making your ideal smart home, you may wonder which smart home hub would be the best for your setup.

If you are also someone who is wondering which one of these is the better option, then you should not need to worry about a thing! We will be using this article to compare both these hubs.

Hubitat vs Wink: Switching Wink To Hubitat

After reading this article, you will have a better idea of which device you will want to buy. Similarly, it is also important to know how long was the product made available.

Coming back to the topic, Samsung SmartThings has been in the market for a long time now. This makes it a lot easier to understand, and most importantly, makes it compatible with most other products that are in the market. On the other hand, Hubitat is quite new. We have seen the product gain a lot of fame in a very short time period.Nowadays there are various smart home automation controllers in the market. In the comparison of Hubitat vs Winkit is seen that they are very much popular, each in their own way.

The former is well known for its ease of use, less complexity and capability to control the devices in the house effectively. And the latter is famous for its extensive automation capabilities, built-in devices and many more. Often times it is seen that even after purchasing one of the best products from the market, they are not satisfied with it.

This article will provide in-depth research on the devices and based on user criteria, will help them make a smart decision. First and foremost, the user has to decide what they really seek from their smart controller. The consumers for Wink and Hubitat can easily be divided into two.

Although bear in mind that the complex features have to handle with care, this means it needs knowledge and it is time-consuming. So if you are not ready to enhance your technical knowledge, invest time and energy. This device is not for you and you should look for something simple. To talk about the simple and flexible use of the device, Wink is the choice. It is known for its unique characteristics for the use of features like Robots and Schedule.

Wink can also work locally some features only. To begin with, this home automation hub is not for the novice. It has more complex features and hence the more integrated and smart outcome is expected as a result. One of the main features that make it unique is its capability to work locally.

This makes the whole system even faster to operate, cloud independent with high security and keeps all data in your control. This hub has easily comprehensible setup and use of system. It is compatible with Google Assistant and Alexa so users can easily use voice commands. Mobile apps are available to control features in the house. The Wink is faster and more reliable.We're a place where coders share, stay up-to-date and grow their careers.

Back inI was getting serious into home automation. I was debating between a SmartThings hub or a Wink hub. That sale kicked my home automation addiction into high gear.

Compared to what I saw from SmartThings, the Wink interface was clean and easy to use. Setup was mostly painless and at the time their support was responsive. Fast forward toWink was going broke, their support was non-existent, service outages are typical and I would go DAYS without being to use wink's service.

LateWink's Google Home integration was down for nearly a week and I finally hit my breaking point.

hubitat vs wink

It was time to switch hubs. Wink Pros: user friendly, easy to set up, works with wide range of devices. Wink Cons: Support nightmare, down all the time, device response can be slow, Cloud based - requires outside internet connection. Hubitat Pros: Community driven, Supports most protocols and devices, Runs Locally on your own network no internet requiredrock solid and stable Hubitat Cons: Complex interface, learning curve, not for beginners.

Like I said above, Wink's setup was pretty painless. You download their app, it walks you through the steps and provides some help when you get stuck. Hubitat wasn't as easy but there is a lot of resources and users on their forums willing to help you out. I took it slow and moved one Z-wave switch from wink to Hubitat.

And it was a total fail!

hubitat vs wink

I had always thought "Z-Wave is Z-Wave" and any switch would work with any hub, turns out that isn't the case. I quickly learned to check the List of Compatible Devices before doing anything else.

Moving compatible devices turned out to be straightforward and mostly painless. One of the first things I noticed was how fast the Hubitat responded, it is freaky fast! Mainly due to running completely local to your network not over the cloud. After years of Wink taking a full second or two on a good day to turn on a light, it was amazing to now see sub second changes!

Sure, a few seconds doesn't sound like a long time, but Wink always felt slow. Imagine using Wink's app, you click the device you want to control, you see a little spinner, then 2 seconds on a good day later the light turns on.

Wink on a bad day was more like seconds, and sometimes not at all! Now imagine you click that device in Hubitat, and the light turns on as fast as the buttons changes on the web page, factions of a second!

It feels as fast as controlling the switch directly. Wink's app is pretty clean, simple and easy to use. Sometimes it can be sluggish, but overall it's a nice app when it works. You'll need to build what Hubitat calls a Dashboard. It starts completely empty and it's up to the user to place buttons on the screen and configure the size, position, color, etc.

You can make a somewhat good looking interface but you will spend some times to get there. Going the Google Home route requires an internet connection, but you can also use the local Hubitat website running locally if your internet goes down. I assume Alexa devices work as well, but I'm not in that camp.

Wink has a feature called Robots that allow you to build simple automations, like time based triggers or actions based on other devices. Hubitat has a complete Rule Machine built in. Wink's robot's are simple to setup but they are also pretty limited


This entry was posted in Hubitat vs wink. Bookmark the permalink.

Responses to Hubitat vs wink

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *